SONG OF THE WEEK — Did ERRA Do Muse BETTER Than Muse?! | Stockholm Syndrome NEWS — Parkway Drive Unleash “Carrion” With Full Orchestra in ‘HOME’ Concert Film EPISODE — Rolling Stone’s 200 Best Songs of the 21st Century… Seriously? | RFR E43 SHOW MOMENT — Fall Out Boy Rolled Into a California Mall and Dropped ‘ACES’ Live for the First Time EPISODE — Metallica In Las Vegas at the Sphere + ERRA Throws Down LEGACY — Oasis Skipping Their Own Rock & Roll Hall of Fame Induction SONG OF THE WEEK — Metallica’s “One” Is Far Deeper Than You Realize – SOTW NEWS — PRESIDENT Claim Radio City Music Hall for May 2027 — Biggest Headline Show Yet EPISODE — 40 – Slipknot Losing Its Fans?! $700 Tickets & Dave Mustaine to EXIT Megadet | Rock Fan Radio NEWS — Kittie’s ‘Oracle’ Gets Full Re-Record for 25th Anniversary — ‘Oracle XXV’ Incoming SONG OF THE WEEK — Breaking Benjamin’s “Dear Agony” & The Agonizing Story Behind it | SOTW | S2E25 NEWS — Clutch 2027 Tour Stacked: C.O.C., Agnostic Front, Chuck Ragan in the Mix EPISODE — 39 – Sober Manson, Cringe Rob Zombie & Riot Fest Mud Bath Mayhem | Rock Fan Radio NEWS — Fall Out Boy Launch ‘Twilight of the Punks’ Stadium Tour in 2027 With The Offspring & Good Charlotte EXTRAS — Pearl Jam Fans Stunned By Abe Laboriel Jr.’s Debut Performance NEWS — Beach Bunny Sign to Atlantic, Drop New Single “Vinegar” + Announce 2027 Tour LET'S GET HEAVY — Is the New Architects Song Even Architects? | Let’s Get Heavy SHOW MOMENT — Killswitch Engage Brought SPEED’s Jem Siow Onstage in Sydney for “My Last Serenade” ROCK REPORT — Sponge’s Final Album?! + Royal Blood & Alien Ant Farm | The Rock Report SHOW MOMENT — Opeth Pulls Bogotá Show as Mikael Åkerfeldt Battles Illness SONG OF THE WEEK — Did ERRA Do Muse BETTER Than Muse?! | Stockholm Syndrome NEWS — Parkway Drive Unleash “Carrion” With Full Orchestra in ‘HOME’ Concert Film EPISODE — Rolling Stone’s 200 Best Songs of the 21st Century… Seriously? | RFR E43 SHOW MOMENT — Fall Out Boy Rolled Into a California Mall and Dropped ‘ACES’ Live for the First Time EPISODE — Metallica In Las Vegas at the Sphere + ERRA Throws Down LEGACY — Oasis Skipping Their Own Rock & Roll Hall of Fame Induction SONG OF THE WEEK — Metallica’s “One” Is Far Deeper Than You Realize – SOTW NEWS — PRESIDENT Claim Radio City Music Hall for May 2027 — Biggest Headline Show Yet EPISODE — 40 – Slipknot Losing Its Fans?! $700 Tickets & Dave Mustaine to EXIT Megadet | Rock Fan Radio NEWS — Kittie’s ‘Oracle’ Gets Full Re-Record for 25th Anniversary — ‘Oracle XXV’ Incoming SONG OF THE WEEK — Breaking Benjamin’s “Dear Agony” & The Agonizing Story Behind it | SOTW | S2E25 NEWS — Clutch 2027 Tour Stacked: C.O.C., Agnostic Front, Chuck Ragan in the Mix EPISODE — 39 – Sober Manson, Cringe Rob Zombie & Riot Fest Mud Bath Mayhem | Rock Fan Radio NEWS — Fall Out Boy Launch ‘Twilight of the Punks’ Stadium Tour in 2027 With The Offspring & Good Charlotte EXTRAS — Pearl Jam Fans Stunned By Abe Laboriel Jr.’s Debut Performance NEWS — Beach Bunny Sign to Atlantic, Drop New Single “Vinegar” + Announce 2027 Tour LET'S GET HEAVY — Is the New Architects Song Even Architects? | Let’s Get Heavy SHOW MOMENT — Killswitch Engage Brought SPEED’s Jem Siow Onstage in Sydney for “My Last Serenade” ROCK REPORT — Sponge’s Final Album?! + Royal Blood & Alien Ant Farm | The Rock Report SHOW MOMENT — Opeth Pulls Bogotá Show as Mikael Åkerfeldt Battles Illness
← Back to News

Jesus and Mary Chain Reject Shoegaze Label, Blame Van Halen

Jesus and Mary Chain Reject Shoegaze Label, Blame Van Halen

WHAT THEY SAID

“I think guitar players should never learn scales. I think the worst guitar players in the world — like Eddie Van Halen.” * William Reid went after Van Halen in a festival interview, blaming him for ruining rock guitar through the ’80s and ’90s by inspiring speed-obsessed imitators. *

THE DETAILS

  • Jim Reid dismissed shoegaze as a made-up term invented by an NME writer, insisting the genre doesn’t actually exist. *
  • The brothers were interviewed at New York’s Total Bummer festival, where Jesus And Mary Chain headlined alongside Dinosaur Jr. over the weekend. *
  • William argued that Van Halen’s note-cramming approach spawned a generation of copycats, and he’d take Peter Hook’s bass riffs over anything Van Halen ever played. *
  • Jim described his own guitar playing as deliberately limited — only playing to the level needed — and suggested that technical knowledge can get in the way of creativity. *

WHO IS RIGHT

William Reid is right that Van Halen’s influence spawned a lot of soulless shredders, but calling Eddie one of the worst guitar players in the world is absurd — “Eruption” changed rock whether you like it or not. The Peter Hook comparison is apples and oranges.

WHAT HAPPENS NEXT

The Reid brothers will keep saying exactly what they think and Van Halen fans will keep being furious about it.

Source ArticlesShow Inline Citations
* Jesus And Mary Chain Say Shoegaze Doesn’t Actually Exist, Eddie Van Halen Ruined Rock Guitar — Tom Breihan, Stereogum, 2026-06-02T16:53:37+00:00 — https://stereogum.com/2501049/jesus-and-mary-chain-say-shoegaze-doesnt-actually-exist-eddie-van-halen-ruined-rock-guitar/news/

On YouTube

We need 633 more of you

No label, no network — just fans building this with us. We're at 367, chasing 1,000. Subscribing on YouTube is the single biggest way to help.

367 / 1,000 subscribers
I'm in — Subscribe on YouTube

On YouTube

You read the whole thing. You're one of us.

The full show — album reactions, interviews, the arguments — lives on YouTube. We're at 367 subs, hunting 1,000. Even if you follow us on Spotify or Apple, the YouTube sub is separate — and it's what puts the show in front of more rock fans so we can build our community together.

367 / 1,000 subscribers
Subscribe on YouTube — Make It 368